Where did you get this idea?

I didn’t knew about Microsoft taking over the fsf either, and I am getting concerned about the real freedom behind my beloved Linux.

I think you are confusing FSF with the Linux Foundation, and you can see MS as part of the platinum LF members. Was that it, or you really meant FSF?

If you have installed wlroots, that’s why. Wlroots has a hard dependency on libseatd, which is provided by seatd. Labwc also directly depends on it. Sway as well can use seatd as both documented by sway itself, and its arch wiki, but for some reason it doesn’t directly depend on it, though it depends on wlroots, :). This is not a problem on arch since the seatd service can co-exist with logind/systemd, and on arch you can use the seatd service combined with libseatd for software build on top of libseatd, and users on arch can then choose between seatd or policy kit on that software. On other non systemd distros like artix, the seatd daemon is in conflict with logind (on artix it’s extracted from systemd), precisely because you can get away without logind as long as you use acpid to provide some of the functionality logind also provides besides session administration. Not sure if besides wlroots on archthere’s additional software depending on seatd. Several wayland compositors are based on wlroots, which attempts to somehow offer a standard for compositor and applications developers.

So it might be xdg-desktop-portal behaves differently for sandboxed apps such as flatpak ones than regular apps, hmm. So I’d still like to know how required d-bus is…

Thanks a lot !

Have you explore hyprland, niri (scrollable, not dynamic, but it’s sort of dynamic then) or sway (static tiling though, but offering tabbed layout and dynamic stacking/floating, plus hugely customizable)? Did you discard them because not close enough to bspwm? Just curious, not to judge your decision or anything like that.

Being an artix user, are you using logind (the official default), or just seatd, or the new logind alternative turnstile (not supported by all init systems, looks like only dinit which I use and openrc, tough void has it working with runit I believe)? I’m wondering what’s really required on wayland. I like the approach of just seatd, but I don’t know what one would lose and what are the wins, but if not seat alone then turnstile which actually require seatd. Also I would like to drop calling d-bus, but I’m not sure if that would prevent the compositor to work, but further if screen sharing with webrtc, electron apps like slack or teams-for-linux would stop working. I guess not using d-bus would not affect mako. But any ways, I’m curious of what would be you choice for your wayland experience if/when you get into it. The official and default way is just logind plus d-bus plus polkit. For such sharing xdg-desktop-portal is required, which fundamentally seems to be plumbing of d-bus, but I’m not sure…

BTW, from the blog post referenced, dudemanguy is also the mpv developer, so that requires quite a lot of effort (mpv specially on the support side of things, besides the developing effort, particularly to support wayland, and mpv does for some time now) together with artix effort. I’m glad he’s back writing, :)

Hey, sorry to take adantage of your answer, perhaps you can help me out though.

Is dbus actually necessary for xdg-desktop-portal? I understand from this flatpak post that xdg-desktop-portal is actually a bunch of d-bus interconnections, which of course make d-bus fundamental for xdg-desktop-portal, but wanted to confirm. xdg-desktop-portal is a must on wayland if one wants to share screen through webrtc, or electron apps like slack or teams-for-linux (probably zoom which is Qt as well). But I’ve read some people (this for example) start sway from console without d-bus, without logind/systemd, just seatd on the background (wlroots and sway support seatd). So perhaps those people are not interested on sharing screen, I don’t know. Or perhaps such d-bus plumbing is only required for flatpaks apps, which are sandboxed, thus requiring all that interconnection to access resources and such, and then I’m not sure about a thing…

Thanks !